
THE U.S.
Thrash Metal took the established order of Heavy Metal and gave it a dark, twisted persona, Death Metal saw that persona and decided to dement it even further. Death Metal is inarguably an American invention and its first pioneers were eager to rid themselves of the shackles of perfect technique and showmanship. Death Metal pioneers opted instead for a sound and image that frightened not because of facepaint and occult lyrics, but because it held up a mirror to society. Death Metal inspired fear by showing people the darkness inherent in themselves. Death Metal thus began as a profoundly different take on the Metal genre and, like Black Metal, it was named before it was conceived.
California’s Possessed is often considered the creator of Death Metal due to the track of the same name on their 1985 release “Seven Churches.” However, what Possessed played was undoubtedly Thrash. It wasn’t until 1987’s “Scream Bloody Gore” that we truly had our first example of Death Metal.
In Death Metal, as a genre, riffs became more chaotic, vocals more tortured and lyrics more heinous, and all three of these descriptors are emphatically present on Death’s debut album, Scream Bloody Gore. Founded just outside of Orlando in Altamonte Springs, Florida by Chuck Schuldiner, Death had as profound an impact on Metal as is possible. The new subgenre mixed the intensity of Metal with Horror film ambience – a combination that’d become yet another worldwide musical phenomenon.
Though born in Orlando, Death Metal’s first home was Tampa, a place not at all characterized by rainy or frigid winters, or majestic mountains and grandiose forests. Death saw the relatively conservative Tampa as an adequate home for the new scene and had already relocated there by the time their second album, “Leprosy,” was released in 1988. Leprosy featured a more polished sound but, more importantly, it also featured more crushing vocals and musicianship. After Leprosy dropped on the Metal scene like an anvil, the rest of Tampa, and the world, decided to follow the musical trend Schuldiner created.
The ensuing scene that formed in Tampa is the finest and most prolific the Americas ever offered to the Metal world. Morbid Angel, Massacre, Deicide, Obituary, Disincarnate, Acheron, Nocturnus, Monstrosity exploded onto the scene bringing with them a new hateful and aggressive sound. Morbid Angel, though they are yet another example of a band refusing to die, is often considered the band that perfected the sound that Death started. And with releases like “Altars of Madness” (1989), “Blessed are the Sick” (1991) and “Covenant” (1993) it is not hard to see why. Morbid Angel gave Death Metal a sense of desperation and anger that Schuldiner could not.
Obituary put another spin on the Death Metal sound giving it a dystopian edge fronted by the sadistic vocals of John Tardy. Throw in guitarist extraordinaire and mastermind behind Disincarnate, James Murphy, and you have what is one of the best Metal records ever, “Cause of Death” (1990). Nocturnus joined the scene, the same year that Cause of Death dropped, with their debut “The Key.” What Nocturnus created was as trippy as it was innovative. With a sound something like if Ministry and Cannibal Corpse had a baby, Nocturnus quickly showed that the genre allowed for harmony and melody as well as dissonance and speed. 1990 saw the release of Nocturnus’ debut and Obituary’s stellar sophomore effort but it was the arrival of Deicide that made the year watershed.
While many hail Morbid Angel as the masters of Death Metal, I don’t think anyone can be more synonymous with a genre than Deicide with the Metal of death. Deicide’s eponymous debut featured incomparable atmosphere and relentless brutality that propelled Deicide to the very top of the Death Metal pyramid. Following up with another classic, “Legion,” in 1992, Deicide became the de facto face of the genre before a three year lapse between records led to a streak of mediocre albums that is still going strong. Despite having devised the ideal formula for the Death Metal sound, Deicide was just one of many “safe” bands within the genre.
Deicide may have created the archetype for Death Metal but it was Sarasota’s Atheist that’d create a sound that even the most extreme Metal fans couldn’t yet understand. Atheist never played textbook Death Metal but what they began with on their 1990 debut, “Piece of Time,” was something slightly more conventional. Subsequent releases, “Unquestionable Presence” (1991) and “Elements” (1993), were magical in their ability to challenge convention within an already extreme music scene. Jazz sensibility, virtuoso musicianship and song structures that would make Stravinsky smile, all characterized Atheist’s unique brand of Death Metal. While the mixture of Jazz with a more extreme form of music may seem antithetical, Death Metal pioneers Death went a similar route on their later records and Miami’s Cynic also joined Atheist in forging new sonic paths within Death Metal.
Other lesser known bands did have an impact in the Florida Death Metal scene, like Monstrosity, Acheron, Massacre and Disincarnate. Monstrosity and Massacre played relatively unremarkable Death Metal that could easily go unnoticed if thrown into a random Death Metal mix; Acheron certainly turned up the speed; while Disincarnate, led by the guitar stylings of James Murphy, added some finesse to the Florida scene.
The Florida Death Metal Scene was monumental and unlike few others due to its scope, breadth and quality, but it was by no means alone in North America. New York State joined in the fun with two Buffalo, NY bands, Malevolent Creation and Cannibal Corpse, both of which later relocated to Tampa to garner recognition; the New York City-area also had quite the scene with the likes of Suffocation, Immolation and Ripping Corpse; Pennsylvania gave us Incantation; California produced the seminal Autopsy and Terrorizer; and Canada got in on the deviance and produced the twisted likes of Cryptopsy and Atheist-esque Gorguts garnering some acclaim, albeit from the more underground listener. Outside of Florida however, only Finland and Sweden could ever compete pound for pound insofar as creating a Death Metal scene with purpose, originality and creativity.
FINLAND
While these days Finland is far more known for comical Folk Metal acts, dramatic Goth Metal and pop-ified Doom Death, it was once home to the most brutal, and even inventive Death Metal. The “Finnish Scene” as I am calling it, much like Finland’s population, was centered in the south of the country near Helsinki. Most bands hailed either from the Finnish capital or neighboring Nokia and Loimaa. Though, arguably, Finland’s most acclaimed Death Metal act, Demilich, hailed from Kuopio, in Central Finland.
The early 90s were seminal in the development of metal around the globe, for while in the 80s the fun seemed to be mainly in England, the US, and South America, the 90s witnessed an unprecedented explosion to produce entire Metal scenes, and Extreme Metal at that, on every continent save for Antarctica. But I begin now with the most extreme: Finnish Death Metal.
The first band to get the ball rolling in Finland was Abhorrence, and although the band never made an official, full-length album, their brand of brutal Death Metal was a harbinger of what was to come. On Abhorrence’s two demos, Vulgar Necrolatry (1990) and S/T (1991), particularly on the latter, the band developed a sound that would resonate throughout Scandinavian metal for years to come. Abhorrence’s brand of Death Metal had a dark, almost blackened (though Black Metal did not yet exist) quality, that surely provided the ideal foundation for Finland’s scene.
In nearby Nokia, the band Convulse joined the scene with their first full-length, “World Without God,” with a slow and heavy sort of Death Metal. World Without God paints a perfect picture of 90s Death Metal, for while it paid homage to Metal’s Doom foundations and to Florida’s tremolo deviance, it had a sound unique to Convulse, and unique to Finland for that matter. For Finnish Death Metal, in all of its misanthropy and darkness, was the true forbear to Norway’s Black Metal scene.
1992 saw releases from Amorphis, Purtenance, Demigod, and Sentenced, four juggernauts in the southern Finnish scene. Amorphis is much more known now for their melodic Death Metal tinged with Folk and Pop elements, but their origin is far more sinister. On “Karelian Isthmus,” Amorphis’ only true Death Metal release, the band showcased that Death Metal did have room for melody, although of the minor sort. World-class vocals and catchy riffs all rounded out a solid debut effort. From Nokia, Purtenance released their “Member of Immortal Damnation,” the most tragically overlooked release and band from Finland. Purtenance were by no means newcomers to the scene, having changed their name from Purtenance Avulsion in 1991, and their debut was a monumental one indeed. Member of Immortal Damnation was dark, brooding and crushingly heavy – a true gem. Sentenced, who could more suitably be placed in the Doom Death Metal category became the first Finnish band to articulate this style fully and masterfully, while still drawing heavily from bands like Dismember in Sweden. Finland’s heaviest Death Metal band Demigod, also released their debut, and only major release in their original formation, “Slumber of Sullen Eyes,” a timeless classic, as brutal as it is enjoyable.
As with the Florida scene, it was only a matter of a couple of years before bands began deviating from the norm of brutality and heaviness. In 1993, Demilich released their debut “Nespithe” in all of its technical wonder and grindcore-esque aggression. Demilich took up the mantle from North Americans Atheist and Gorguts and brought the more Avant-Garde styled Death Metal to Scandinavia. Also Avant-Garde, though nowhere near as good, were Belial from Oulu. Belial released “Never Again,” also in 1993. With peculiar synth passages, silly growls and rather unorthodox riffs, Never Again made a lasting impression but, perhaps, for the wrong reasons.
1994 witnessed a quick decline to the greatness produced with Convulse defecting to the Death n’ Roll sound pioneered by Swedes Entombed, and yet it marked the birth of a new genre: Funeral Doom. The only highlights of the “post-93” era coming with Funeral Doom pioneers Thergothon releasing “Stream from the Heavens,” an album as crushing as it was thought-provoking, and Adramalech debuting their first full-length, “Psychostasia” in 1996, a time-honored masterpiece whose raw production and haunting vocals remind me of their countrymen in Beherit.
The crowning achievement for the Finnish Death Metal scene is that we still discuss it in Metal today, an impressive feat for a scene that came and went with so many bands only producing one or two releases before splitting up. But unlike the Finns, the Swedish Death Metal bands would commit a far greater crime than breaking up too soon, which is never breaking up.
SWEDEN
Where Finland produced quality over quantity in most cases, Sweden did both, but diminishing marginal utility is certainly applicable here. Sweden was the first country in Scandinavia to really run with Metal, especially more extreme forms, and it too began with Thrash. While the US bands hand already evolved Thrash into Death Metal by the late 80s, the Swedes were still producing noteworthy Satanic Thrash into the 90s. Three bands iconified this period: Morbid, Treblinka and Merciless.
Stockholm’s Morbid is mostly known for having introduced infamous Mayhem frontman, Per Yngve Ohlin, AKA “Dead,” but few take the time to listen to these masters of dark, diabolical Thrash. Morbid released their December Moon Demo in 1987 and featured unsettling ambience brought to you by excellent guitar work and Attila Csihar-inspired vocals. After Dead left for Mayhem in 1988, the band made one more demo before splitting up. Also, in 1988 Treblinka, later named Tiamat, released its first Demo entitled “Crawling in Vomits.” The most lo-fi and raw of Sweden’s “big three” of Thrash, Treblinka produced thrash that was less crazed in speed and aggression but more than made up for it in atmosphere and attitude. Finally, in 1990, Sweden’s paramount year as far as becoming a factory capable of pumping out the most exquisite metal, Merciless released “The Awakening.” Merciless’ debut effort adorns the Halls of Thrash Metal Greatness along with the likes of Sepultura and Pentagram (CHILE), and is as perfect as an album can be. Establishing a tight, but world-class, Satanic Thrash scene allowed bands to take that formula and do what metalheads always do: MAKE IT HEAVIER.
While Treblinka’s first album under a new moniker, Tiamat, was by no means the heaviest album in 1990 it marked a new, much darker face to the Swedish Metal scene. “Sumerian Cry” featured exasperated vocals and that delicious guitar tone that would define Swedish Death Metal. Not to be outdone however, were the likes of Carnage and Entombed. Carnage and Entombed incorporated a hardcore edge to their sound, which can still be heard in copycats bands today. Carnage’s debut, “Dark Recollection,” featured all the buzzsaw riffs and howls one could expect from Death Metal but with the added aggression of the D-Beat. Carnage also featured a star-studded lineup, featuring Fred Estby, David Blomqvist and Matti Kärki of Dismember, as well as Michael Amott of Carcass/Arch Enemy. Entombed, already having established themselves under the name Nihilist, did much of the same on “Left Hand Path” leaving Stockholmers unsure if they should mosh or headbang; the answer was of course both. Cult Death Metallers Nirvana 2002, never having made an official release, released their “Disembodied Spirits” Demo also in 1990. The Demo is still more than worthy of a listen for it is only enhanced by its shoddy production, for it was not so poor as to miss out on the atmosphere provided by wailing guitar solos and even some keys.
So 1990 established three things for the bands to come in the Swedish Death Metal Scene. Firstly, it would be far more “in your face” than its American counterpart, featuring music that was far angrier than it was dark. Secondly, like Florida’s scene, it would birth a new mecca in Gothenburg, though I’ve yet to mention any of those bands. And lastly, tone is god!
And no single band captured Sweden’s beloved distortion like Dismember on their 1991 debut “Like an Everflowing Stream.” The tremolo picking married with the crunchy gain and lower tuning created a devilish sound, one that would leave the whole world envious. Entombed followed up their debut with “Clandestine” another classic for the crossover pioneers before they decided to “cross the streams.” Also in the Stockholm scene, was Unleashed who made their debut in 1991 with “Where No Life Dwells,” which, although clearly featuring a sort of hardcore edge, was far-more Metal than their fellow citizens. And if one should be looking for pure, unadulterated Death Metal, they need look no further than Grave’s debut that same year. “Into the Grave” was certainly Swedish, but the growls and riffs were mostly of the ripping and banging sort, and even featured the odd blastbeast, uncommon in the age of the D-Beat (which the album also features in abundance). Stockholm ruled the Swedish Death Metal scene in its infancy but one band would forever change that narrative: AT THE GATES.
At the Gates made Stockholm seem like Orlando and made Gothenburg Tampa. In other words, in Sweden, Death Metal had its home. While Entombed and Dismember began to die n’ roll into musical obscurity, At the Gates came into to breathe chaos and life into Sweden’s burgeoning scene with dystopian tunes that seem as much from planet earth as the pyramids at Giza (shout out to all the flat-earth fools and alien-loving lunatics [neither of which I am]). “Gardens of Grief” hit in 1991 as a statement of purpose, what At the Gates had to offer was nothing like what the lads in Stockholm had, it was crazed, spooky and spat in the face of convention, even if that convention was already within the framework of extreme Metal. Followed up with their first full-length in 1992, At the Gates made another major statement with “The Red in the Sky is Ours.” What statement? We refuse to be restrained.
The Red in the Sky is Ours is a relentless onslaught of the most tortured vocals in Swedish history, inventive, and even odd-time drumming, and delightfully complex riffs that completely dispelled any notion that they were simply just another Death Metal band from Sweden. But it was with “With Fear I Kiss the Burning Darkness” that, in 1993, the epicenter for Swedish Death Metal became Gothenburg. With Fear… took the established psychosis from The Red… and made it angrier and more deranged, a landmark in every sense of the term. At the Gates set the bar so high that they themselves would never come close to a record so brilliant again. Perhaps making it to their 20s dampened their creativity. But what is certain is that subsequent albums “Terminal Spirit Disease” and “Slaughter of the Soul,” while undeniably catchy, cannot compare to the sheer genius of the albums which preceded them. And thus it would be the sound created on those latter albums that the Gothenburg scene would emulate with varying degrees of success.
The characteristics of the Gothenburg sound were melody, harmony and what I describe as the “half-time” blast (not a true blast for the bass and snare alternate hits). And while no band reached the same heights as At the Gates, some came pretty darn close. Eucharist being my vote for the closest rival (Disclaimer: not from Gothenburg but certainly of the same ilk). The use of melody, precise drumming (brought to you by Daniel Erlandsson of Arch Enemy fame), and a hardcore edge may not in and of itself make a unique sound in Sweden but the way that Eucharist did so on their debut “A Velvet Creation” is noteworthy to say the least. The album is simply gorgeous and evocative, possessing character and emotional depth unlike most others in the Death Metal genre. Beside Eucharist are myriad good bands but none quite as good.
A year before Eucharist’s debut, Liers in Wait, actually from Gothenburg, released “Spiritually Uncontrolled Art,” (sneakily similar to the term later used by At the Gates “Suicidal Final Art”). A solid effort though not at all in-keeping with the Gothenburg sound. Liers in Wait, whose founding members had been bandmates with At the Gates vocalist Tomas Lindberg in Grotesque, played probably the most straightforward brand of Death Metal in the whole of Sweden but only ever released an EP. The true historical value of Liers in Wait lay with their guitarist Jan Kristian “Necrolord” Wahlin who designed the album covers for an impressive host of bands (Noteworthy: Emperor, “In the Nightside Eclipse; Sacramentum, “Far Away from the Sun”; Wintersun, S/T). The band eventually renamed and rebranded as Diabolique, a decent Goth Metal project. Liers in Wait may have been the first act to join At the Gates in making Gothenburg the new home to Swedish Death Metal, but they were nowhere near as consequential as Dark Tranquility and In Flames, both of which helped shape the overall sound of the Gothenburg scene.
Dark Tranquility and In Flames can often be spoken of in the same breath, for not only did the bands employ melody far more than their contemporaries, they also suffered similar fates. Dark Tranquility hit the scene with their 1993 debut “Skydancer” and In Flames the following year with “Lunar Strain” thus creating a new subgenre: Melodic Death Metal. To many this is an abomination for they misunderstand melody. Some pseudo-musicologists confuse and misuse terms like atonal and amelodic to describe music that to more conventional listeners can be described as “ugly.” But Melodic Death Metal is not at all antithetical. Death Metal is about attitude and aggression and there is no loss of aggression in bands like Eucharist, Dark Tranquility and In Flames – at least on their earlier releases.
By 1993 Melodic Death Metal was a force within metal with even Grindcore extraordinaires Carcass joining the fold with “Heartwork” (still considered part of the Gothenburg sound by some due to the band featuring Michael Amott). Several other bands joined in on the sound such as: Hypocrisy (though originally more akin to Entombed), Unanimated, A Canorous Quintet, Gates of Ishtar and Ablaze my Sorrow. But, as the old adage goes, “all good things must come to an end.” And many bands in the Gothenburg scene only had one or two good albums in them. Eucharist’s follow-up was disappointing, In Flames quickly became Mallcore, and most simply disappeared. But regrettably many bands (In Flames, Dark Tranquility, At the Gates) continue to make sorry attempts at maintaining/reviving that old Gothenburg sound when all we really need is revisit the albums from 1991-6. Once again, knowing when to quit is oftentimes more important than knowing how to start.
Though Sweden’s Death Metal scene produced albums that have, and will continue to, endure the test of time, Death Metal was never owned by a single scene or country. Sweden had simultaneous scenes in Stockholm and Gothenburg, all while Finland had their gruesome Death Metal scene in full effect. But for those turned off by the mindless aggression of Death Metal, put off by the speed of Melodic Death Metal, and never even heard of Grindcore Death Metal (which I won’t be discussing), there was another subgenre evolving in the early 90s that is near and dear to my heart.
DOOM DEATH METAL
Doom Death Metal may be the earliest instance of cross-subgenre fusion for it took the earliest form of metal’s riffs and tempo and fused it with Death Metal’s atmosphere and vocal stylings yielding something new and glorious. And, in Doom Death Metal, we also have our first scene not determined by geography (mostly).
The origin of the subgenre known as Doom Death began in Halifax, UK with the band Paradise Lost. Paradise Lost’s debut “Lost Paradise,” once more turned the metal world’s attention back to England. Featuring a forlorn vibe and growls, this was not Tampa Death Metal, it was something new. With riffs that sounded as if Tony Iommi had lost all of his fingers, drums that crushed, and my vote for the best growls in history, Paradise Lost came to forever change the complexion of underground Metal. They taught metalheads that one needn’t write only about gore and satan to be edgy, and that there was room within Metal for thinkers. In 1991, Paradise Lost released “Gothic” and fully established the Doom Death sound and vibe.
Fellow Halifax natives, My Dying Bride, were quick to join in the sadness. “As the Flower Withers” dropped in 1992 and was no ripoff. My Dying Bride growled more heinously, and had a heavier heavy and a slower slow. And though they eventually morphed into a Goth Metal band they were still invaluable contributors to the Doom Death genre. Also in 1992, Anathema, from Liverpool, released their “Crestfallen” EP and thus made Doom Death a full-fledged scene (though Anathema were a poor excuse for Doom Death, if compared to Paradise Lost and My Dying Bride). Not to be outdone by the motherland however, Australia soon retorted with one of the most enigmatic bands in Metal history: DISEMBOWELMENT.
Though Disembowelment’s first Demo was released in 1990, playing a crazed sort of Death Metal, it was with their full-length that the band articulated a sound that never was and shall nevermore come again. “Transcendence into the Peripheral” is a mind-altering experience, for the listener is confronted with an album that is both hideous and beautiful, angry and sad, contemplative and impulsive. Disembowelment is often referred to as Doom Death for they were slow and brooding at times, while at others they were relentless and merciless. But to truly describe Transcendence into the Peripheral in a tagline is impossible. Only listening is believing on this one. Though Disembowelment heightened the new subgenre with their one and only full-length they were by no means the only ones. Many others joined in as one-LP-wonders.
New York produced Winter who released their only full-length, “Into Darkness,” in 1990 which was an album destined to be as slow and heavy as possible. While it is certainly good it is neither particularly slow or heavy. Visceral Evisceration, from Vienna, released their demented take on Doom Death in 1994. “Incessant Desire for Palatable Flesh” walked a fine line between parody and genius, and the verdict is still out. Funeral Doom pioneers Thergothon released their only full-length also in 1994. “One and done” was the MO for many in Doom Death but not all.
Once Thergothon laid the foundation for Funeral Doom, fellow Finns, Skepticism, joined in with their full-length debut. “Stormcrowfleet” was released in 1995, and made something far more ambient and epic than Thergothon, though equally slow. Dungeon Synth fans would find much to love here. Subsequent EP, “Ethere,” and LP, “Lead and Aether,” did not disappoint in creating beautiful soundscapes that intrigue and depress. Norway’s Funeral put a more unique spin on Funeral Doom by adding acoustic guitar passages, electric guitar solos and clean vocals, on their now cult classic release “Tragedies” (released in 1995), but they too eventually went in a Goth direction. In rounding out the Scandinavian “big three” Sweden also produced quality Doom Death though not of the Funeral Doom variety.
In Stockholm, friends Jonas Renkse, Anders Nyström and Mikael Akerfeldt too had their fingers on the pulse of the Doom Death sound, teaming up on Katatonia’s second full-length “Brave Murder Day,” released in 1996. Though Katatonia was already well-established in the genre since their 1993 album, “Dance of December Souls,” as was Mikael’s band Opeth, with its debut “Orchid” in 1995, the collaboration produced a monumental record that was melodic, catchy and emotive, everything good Doom Death should be (Jonas lost his ability to scream and growl shortly before the recording). Brave Murder Day ended up being the genre’s swansong for after 1996, all of the original Doom Death Bands (save for Skepticism really) evolved away from their downtrodden, slow beginnings or simply broke up. Doom Death never really died, however, for it saw a resurgence in the 2000s (and continues until today), though those who paved the way for those bands had already moved on.
EPILOGUE
Death Metal, like with all Metal subgenres, splintered into different scenes and sounds, which is part of why we metalheads love it so. Everyone has their own take on Metal, whether it be for cultural, linguistic, geographical or personal reasons. But never would a place be so significant to creating a subgenre as Norway’s impact on Black Metal.
